Feedback and situational leadership
5 min read
Lesson objectives
- Describe observed behavior and impact without attributing motive, then adjust task direction and support for a specific assignment as new evidence appears.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
A learning-team member delivers a session plan on time, yet its activity instructions never say what the facilitator should collect from learners. ‘Be more professional’ leaves the designer without a clear action; ‘you failed’ invites a defensive exchange. Describe the specific situation, the observed behavior, and its effect on work, then listen to the explanation and agree on a testable revision. The APTD outline includes knowledge of feedback principles and leadership theories, including transformational, inclusive, and situational leadership. This does not require assigning permanent personality labels. It requires understanding how a leader's action can vary with the aim and the state of a particular task.
The situation–behavior–impact approach offers a practical feedback frame. Situation: ‘In Tuesday's trial of activity two.’ Behavior: ‘The instruction said discuss the case but did not identify an output or time.’ Impact: ‘Three facilitators asked how to close the activity, and the test paused for ten minutes.’ These are preliminary observations, not a verdict that the designer is careless. After describing them, ask what the designer intended and what change would make the output visible. The response may reveal that a separate facilitator sheet existed but was not distributed. Then the right fix may be to attach it and test access, rather than rewriting the whole activity. The feedback giver must also be prepared to correct an incomplete account.
After identifying the gap, choose direction and support for the task rather than for the whole person. A designer may write strong learning outcomes yet be new to facilitating a virtual discussion. Do not remove autonomy in the first skill or leave them without a model in the second. When the steps are unfamiliar, give a criterion and short example and check the first attempt. When they know the steps but lack a resource, remove the obstacle and ask for their alternative. When attempts are reliable, delegate the decision and set a review point for the result. This is a cautious application of fitting leadership to the situation: a working hypothesis to revise, not a formula promising that one style works with everyone.
Compare three leadership lenses in this same problem. A transformational lens explains why the activity matters for helping learners perform at work and may encourage a better design; it does not replace exact instructions. An inclusive lens invites the future facilitators, including a person using an alternative access tool, to test the instructions before approval; it does not mean accepting every suggestion without a criterion. A situational lens adjusts the support given now to the designer's experience with this assignment and the real constraints. Vision, participation, and direction can work together if the result remains observable: tested instructions that another facilitator can follow to obtain a defined output within the stated time.
Avoid two opposite errors. The first uses feedback as a final judgment about a person rather than a description of changeable behavior in an event. The second turns leadership style into a reward or punishment: ‘I delegate if I trust you; otherwise I monitor you.’ Explain the link between support, task risk, and clarity of the steps. Write a small agreement: What changes? Who retests it? What counts as success? When will you review the result? If new evidence appears, such as a facilitator succeeding while a screen-reader user cannot access the sheet, do not declare universal success. Add an appropriate access test. A professional relationship should be joined to a quality criterion, not merely to both parties feeling comfortable with the conversation.
Lesson summary
Describe observed behavior and impact without attributing motive, then adjust task direction and support for a specific assignment as new evidence appears.