Expense accrual, impairment and comparing the two frameworks
8 min read
Lesson objectives
- Compute period expenses, accruals and prepayments, measure impairment losses under IFRS and U.S. GAAP, and identify the questions needed before comparing the profit of two entities under different frameworks.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
Expense recognition follows the benefit consumed or obligation incurred, not merely the date cash moves. A service wage earned this month but paid next month is this month's wage expense and payable. A 12-month insurance premium paid now is a prepaid asset until coverage is consumed; if 24 buys twelve equal months and three months pass, expense is 6 and prepaid balance 18. Depreciation systematically allocates a depreciable asset's cost over the periods benefited without a current cash payment. An expected assurance-warranty cost is recognized when the related sale and obligation arise if the estimate meets the applicable criteria; a merely hoped-for future expenditure is not accrued. Match costs to revenue or period benefits without inventing precise causation.
For IFRS IAS 36, test an intangible with indefinite life, an intangible not yet ready for use and acquired goodwill annually; test other assets when indicators arise. If an individual asset lacks independent cash flows, use the cash-generating unit (CGU) and compare carrying value with recoverable amount, the higher of value in use and fair value less disposal costs. Allocate a CGU impairment to goodwill first, then other assets within limits. Reverse an improved non-goodwill asset only up to its no-impairment carrying amount; never reverse goodwill impairment. U.S. GAAP held-and-used long-lived groups generally first test recoverability against undiscounted cash flows and, if unrecoverable, measure loss against fair value; later reversal of that held-and-used loss is generally prohibited. Apply goodwill's separate reporting-unit model rather than the long-lived group screen.
Compare six U.S. GAAP/IFRS families with the transaction and policy specified. (1) Share awards: IFRS 2 recognizes employee service over vesting and estimates service-condition forfeitures; U.S. Topic 718 allows an entity-wide election to estimate those forfeitures or recognize them as they occur. Defined-benefit plans: IAS 19 measures service cost and net interest in profit and remeasurements in OCI without later recycling, while U.S. Topic 715 generally initially records actuarial gains/losses in OCI and amortizes amounts into later pension cost under its rules. Neither framework permits ignoring compensation or a pension obligation merely because cash pays later.
(2) Intangibles: IAS 38 expenses research but capitalizes development once all feasibility, intent, resources, expected benefits and reliable-measurement criteria are demonstrated; U.S. GAAP generally expenses R&D as incurred, with specific software-development exceptions after technological feasibility. IAS 38 allows revaluation of a recognized intangible only in the rare presence of an active market; routine upward revaluation is not an ordinary U.S. GAAP intangible policy. A purchased patent with a finite life is amortized, while indefinite-life assets are tested, so label the asset and stage before comparison. (3) Inventory: IAS 2 permits FIFO and weighted average for interchangeable goods but not LIFO and generally uses lower of cost and NRV; U.S. GAAP allows LIFO and keeps lower-of-cost-or-market for LIFO and retail inventory, while other methods use lower of cost and NRV. IFRS allows reversal of a prior inventory write-down when NRV recovers, capped at cost; U.S. GAAP generally retains the reduced cost basis.
(4) Leases: U.S. Topic 842 keeps operating and finance classifications for a lessee although both ordinarily create right-of-use assets and liabilities; IFRS 16 uses a single lessee model for most leases, generally separating depreciation and interest instead of U.S. operating single lease expense. (5) Long-lived assets: IAS 16 permits a consistently applied revaluation model by asset class and requires separate depreciation of significant components; U.S. GAAP normally keeps the cost model and does not require component depreciation. Both can capitalize qualifying borrowing costs, so this is a point of shared principle rather than a universal difference; IAS 23 explicitly requires directly attributable costs of a qualifying asset, while U.S. scope and capitalization period must be checked under Topic 835. (6) Impairment: IAS 36 uses recoverable amount and may reverse non-goodwill losses within a cap; U.S. held-and-used long-lived groups use an undiscounted recoverability screen, fair-value measurement of loss and generally no reversal. Goodwill is not reversed under either framework.
Lesson summary
Expense follows the benefit consumed rather than the payment date, impairment is measured by the applicable framework's test, and comparing frameworks starts by fixing the transaction and policy before the figures.