Engagement contract and decision memo
4 min read
Lesson objectives
- Negotiate deliverables feasible within the time and evidence available, and document approval, constraints and open questions in a decision record.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
An advisory engagement should not begin with a slide deck about ‘the sector's future’ when no decision can use it. After the decision frame and assumption register, agree in writing on purpose, authority, scope, horizon, deliverables, due date, readers and reviewers. A deliverable might be an annotated signal register, contrasting scenarios, an option stress-test matrix, or a concise decision memo. Do not promise more than the time and evidence allow at acceptable quality. Name who can grant access to operations data, who will check definitions and assumptions, and when the data version will be frozen for analysis. State how dissent and inference limits will be reported. These terms prevent late conflict when a sponsor expects a definitive forecast but the adviser provides conditional scenarios. Investment choice remains with the client; it is not an automatic output of the expert's method.
For a ten-day deadline, one honest short path could allocate day one to the decision question and options, two days to available evidence and definitions, two to interviews across differing interests, two to building at least two futures and testing options, one to reviewing calculations, and two to the memo and owner discussion. This is an illustrative work budget, not a universal project calendar. If evidence or access makes a stage impossible, record the constraint and narrow the resulting claim. When asked for a ‘comprehensive report’ in ten days, offer a bounded decision review now with known gaps, or a broader study and delayed decision if postponement is feasible. The real tradeoff includes the cost of delay and the risk of early commitment; calling the long option ‘better’ without those consequences does not advise the owner.
Make the decision memo readable without its author in the room. Open with an action sentence such as ‘I recommend a conditional trial’ or ‘the evidence does not yet support fixed investment’. Explain why, the strongest alternative, the disadvantage accepted, and what would reverse the advice. Use a small table to separate verified observations from assumptions and needed tests. State the scope of application: an answer for two districts may not apply city-wide. Avoid a numerical ranking that hides value weights never agreed with the owner. Name the decision owner, implementation owner and next review date instead of assigning all three to ‘management’. In a change log, preserve who changed a criterion and why, when new evidence arrived, and which memo version the board read. If an influential party dissents, describe the objection fairly and address its effect rather than leave disagreement in an ownerless appendix.
Lesson summary
Make the decision memo readable without its author in the room.