Frame the problem and protection gap

Review questions

Frame the problem and protection gap

Registry coverage does not imply effective protection for everyone meeting a programme rule. Begin with denominator, period and counting unit: timely payment among enrollees differs from timely receipt among all eligible households. State uncertainty around estimated eligibility and missing cases, then locate the service-stage bottleneck. When a sponsor demands proof of reduced hardship without baseline or comparison, diagnose decisions and payments now and reserve impact claims for suitable design. Registries describe people inside them; a sound survey may reach non-applicants; interviews suggest mechanisms but cannot size them alone. Do not average rates with unlike definitions. Align them, name rival explanations and specify a prediction that separates each. In a case where files stall at document upload, a small assisted-access test may be warranted while the number of non-starters remains unknown.

Review questions

Test your understanding with these questions. Marking and saved results are available with a free account.

  1. Question 1An agency wants proof that a benefit reduced hardship, but has three months of payment records and no hardship baseline. Which advisory question can be addressed now?
  2. Question 2A cumulative registry says 80%, a quarterly survey 58%, and interviews come from one service centre. What first check makes comparison more defensible?
  3. Question 3Using the lesson data, the agency wants the share of eligible households that received the benefit on time. Which calculation answers that question?
  4. Question 4There are 3,900 timely recipients among 4,800 enrollees. An official calls the 900-person difference rejected claims. What is the best advisory response when 300 were paid late?
  5. Question 5With a fixed budget, the choice is a categorical child benefit or income testing with stale data. What should be compared first?
  6. Question 6Of 400 households meeting a programme rule, 280 receive support. What is exclusion under that rule?
  7. Question 7Digital intake completes 75% and an assisted desk 85%, but desk decisions are slower. What is a suitable first follow-up?
  8. Question 8A 200-unit benefit arrives in half the months against a 500-unit monthly purpose-specific basket. What is a bounded adequacy description if prices stay fixed?
  9. Question 9A committee weighted reach 40% and equity 25%, then new evidence reduced one option's equity score from three to two. What should follow?
  10. Question 10A campaign costs 150,000 and forecasts 400 additional timely recipients. What does 375 mean?
  11. Question 11An agency approves 1,000 cases; its payment provider returns 920 successful settlements and 80 failures. Which count is confirmed paid?
  12. Question 12A control holds 100 transactions and twenty are true duplicates. Which hold-precision measure should accompany delay harm?
  13. Question 13Document assistance raises completed applications, but verification capacity remains below inflow. Which theory-of-change link needs review?
  14. Question 14Of 1,000 households due payment, 780 are confirmed on time and forty await settlement. What can be reported now?
  15. Question 15Hardship falls 40% to 30% for recipients and 35% to 30% for a comparison group. What is the difference in changes, in percentage points?
  16. Question 16Overall reach gains ten points, but a group loses fifteen; the pilot rule bars a drop above five. What first decision follows?
  17. Question 17Payment repair forecasts 600 additional recipients, but this was not measured. How should advice state it?
  18. Question 18An agency has 100,000 recipients and raises value by 50 monthly over twelve unchanged cycles. What is extra transfer commitment before administration?
  19. Question 19A household challenges stale income in its record and service staff identify an urgent protection concern. How should roles be split?
  20. Question 20Of an estimated 10,000 eligible households, 8,000 enrol and 6,000 receive on time. What does 60% represent?