Frame the question and reconstruct claims · Lesson 3

Reconstruct an argument and map its reasons

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Apply reconstruct an argument and map its reasons to a case with defined evidence.
Reading tools

At a meeting about extending a service centre's hours, someone says: “People want evening service; the survey supports it; the centre next door stays open until nine; so we should stay open until nine.” The word “so” helps locate the conclusion but does not show how the reasons support it. An argument is an attempt to give reasons for a claim, not necessarily a quarrel. State the conclusion precisely: “This centre should receive the public until 9 p.m.” Then restate each reason in a form that can be checked. “People want it” leaves open how many people were asked, who they were, and what question they answered. The neighbour's hours do not establish demand here; its location, costs, and users may differ.

An argument map makes the structure visible. Some reasons support a conclusion independently. Evening demand and affordable operating costs might each add a different consideration. Other reasons must work together: a forecast of 160 visits after seven and staffing capacity to handle 160 visits under the approved cost limit. Forecast visits alone do not make the extension feasible, and available staff alone do not make it useful. Group linked premises instead of drawing separate arrows that imply either is sufficient. A premise may also support another premise: a representative survey method supports an estimate of evening demand, which in turn supports the decision. That is a chain, not a direct arrow from “representative” to “open until nine.”

An argument often relies on an unstated bridging premise. Between “some respondents prefer nine” and “we should open until nine” lies an assumption that their preference reflects enough actual demand to justify the costs and that a cheaper alternative, such as online booking, would not meet it. Write the bridge charitably and testably, rather than inventing an extreme claim to defeat. It could say: “If expected demand in the extra hours meets our agreed benefit-and-cost threshold, and no lower-cost option provides comparable access, extending hours is appropriate.” Once visible, the bridge directs the evidence request: unserved bookings, likely visits, shift costs, and other access routes.

Language markers are clues, not a substitute for analysis. “Because” may introduce a reason, but “Tell me because I need to know” does not itself state an argument. “Clearly” adds no evidence. A conclusion may come first: “Extend the hours; we lost many evening appointments.” Neither sentence order nor a speaker's confidence determines strength. Identify the claim the speaker wants accepted. Then ask whether each premise is supported, relevant, and sufficient with the others for the proposed conclusion. A tidy map can still carry weak evidence if “people want it” comes from only twelve voluntary responses.

The strength of an action claim also matters. “Try an evening shift for one month” asks less of the evidence than “Extend hours permanently.” The same preliminary data might justify a reversible pilot without justifying a standing change. Reconstruct the strongest fair version that fits the speaker's context, then state its limits. If the speaker also asserts a binding staffing policy, mark it for verification; analysing the reasons does not give the analyst authority to change that policy.

Lesson summary

Reconstruct an argument and map its reasons: the lesson links the check to a worked case and practice.