Resource development decision inputs · Lesson 4

Qualifying a supporter and choosing the next step

6 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Prepare a qualification card separating evidence from assumption and choose research, exploratory engagement, an authorized ask or a pause without an unsupported wealth estimate.
Reading tools

‘Strong prospect’ should not mean a familiar name or a large employer. Qualification is a staged decision: do we have documented grounds for a relationship around a defined need, may we make contact, and what question must be answered before a request? A person may make small regular gifts and state an interest in children's reading. That is a clear connection even if capacity for a larger gift is unknown. A large company may have no stated connection to the neighborhood or reading program. Size alone is not a reason to send a request. The specialist separates known facts, plausible questions and unknowns instead of ranking people by imagined wealth.

Use a four-part card. Linkage asks how the person or entity connects to the mission or community. Interest records what the prospect has expressed, not what the fundraiser projects onto them. Capacity or financial fit considers whether there is a reliable, permitted signal relevant to a possible commitment, without inferring personal income from appearance or address. Permission and boundaries record whether the current contact preference allows this purpose and channel and whether any proposed condition or conflict needs review. These fields need not all have numerical scores. ‘Unknown, explore appropriately’ or ‘pause because contact was declined’ is more useful than a precise-looking total unsupported by evidence.

For each entry, record the evidence, its date, its source and the access limit. ‘Gave to the library in February’ may be a confirmed internal transaction. ‘Wants to fund shelving’ needs the person's statement or a reliable meeting note. ‘Can fund the whole library’ does not follow from either fact. If a company posts information publicly, check that it belongs to the right entity and that organizational policy permits its use for this specific purpose. Collect no more personal detail than the next decision needs. Where identity records conflict or anonymity has been requested, do not copy the prospect's details into a general presentation. Review the minimum necessary information with the data owner before sharing a detailed card.

Choose a next step proportionate to the evidence. Clear linkage and interest with unknown financial fit call for an exploratory conversation that listens before naming a large ask. With neither linkage nor permission, ‘send a campaign and see’ is not sound qualification. Legitimate research into an organization's public priorities or a pause may be the right step. An offer with a burdensome or conflicting condition should be referred under gift-acceptance policy before entering it as expected revenue. The specialist cannot promise acceptance or a benefit in return simply because a qualification card exists. Authority to accept a gift sits elsewhere.

Make the card actionable with three fields: next step, reason, and the condition that would change the decision. For example: ‘Invite the person to a program visit through a channel they agreed to, because their stated library interest is recent; do not ask for a specific sum until their current interests are understood.’ A reversal condition might be a request to stop contact, which should cancel the invitation and update the record. Name the relationship owner and a review date. ‘Ready to ask’ is not a permanent status. Check with the owner before contact, particularly when another department already has a relationship, so the person does not receive two conflicting requests.

A simple matrix can organize discussion, but do not present it as a predictive model without testing. One axis can reflect documented linkage and another stated interest. Treat permission as an independent entrance condition, never as a low score compensated by other points. The best people for an initial conversation are not necessarily those guessed to have the most money; they are those with an honest reason to talk. After a conversation, update the card with what the person actually said and correct old assumptions. A useful quality measure is how many cards a colleague can interpret and trace back to their sources, not merely how many names entered the pipeline.

Lesson summary

Qualify a prospect using supported linkage, interest, capacity and contact permission. Choose research, cultivation or pause, recording the reason and what needs further verification.