Decision framing and evidence ledger Review questions Decision framing and evidence ledger Advice starts with a decision question, not a demand for certainty about war. In the fictional corridor we identified the decision maker, ninety-day horizon, critical cargo and cost ceiling. A notice of two diversions was kept apart from an interpretation of their cause. Sources were aligned by time and unit: a change in vessels served is not a change in one carrier’s trip duration. The network exposed shared cold storage between apparent alternatives and showed that a route missing the deadline is not an equivalent substitute. The provisional diagnosis is exposure to delay and common dependence, while the delay’s cause remains testable. Compare wholesale diversion, no change and a limited revisable move, then condition action on verified capacity and bookings. A decisive fact can alter the choice before booking closes; a report arriving later cannot. These teaching cases do not establish conditions at a real strait or authorize a legal finding or certainty about state intent.
Review questions Test your understanding with these questions. Marking and saved results are available with a free account.
Question 1 In the fictional port case, a carrier notice establishes only that two ships were rerouted, while the director asks for a definitive war forecast. Which question should guide the advice? What single numerical probability of war follows from the imminent-closure headline? Which shipping arrangement over ninety days limits interruption risk within a stated cost ceiling? How can we prove that the carrier rerouted the ships because of a confirmed military intention? Question 2 A port served 18 vessels rather than 20 while one carrier's trip rose from 8 to 12 days. Which account preserves the measurement units? Vessels served fell 10% and that carrier's trip time rose 50%; the cause remains to be tested. Port capacity fell 50% because trip time rose by that amount. Port service improved 10% because 18 vessels arrived despite delay. Question 3 Two sea routes use one cold-storage hub. What first tests whether diversification works for sensitive cargo? Only the number of countries the vessels cross. Independent cooling capacity if the shared hub fails. Only the geographic distance between the two ports. Question 4 A memo blames carrier delay on security escalation while the port log suggests congestion, but the observation days differ. What comes first? Remove the port log because it conflicts with the favored account. State both explanations, align observation periods and seek a discriminating fact. Count supporting links for each account and pick the larger set. Question 5 Booking closes tonight; cold-slot confirmation arrives in two hours and a seasonal report next week. Which information should precede booking? The seasonal report because it is longer. Cold-slot confirmation because it can change feasibility before the deadline. None; assume ten slots exist unless disproved. Question 6 A minister promises capacity for 20 shipments, but bookings allow 6 and cooling 8. What is the immediate limit before expansion? 20 because the political authority outranks operators. 8 because cooling matters more than bookings. 6 because the smallest confirmed gate limits flow. Question 7 An extra shift costs 40 while four new shipments yield 28. How should this inform expected operator behavior? The shift is certain because revenue is positive. A gap of 12 needs funding or other revenue before operation is assumed. The operator is proven politically hostile to the client. Question 8 Nominal military spending rises from 80 to 100 with 20% inflation. Which initial inference is justified? Real growth is about 4.2%, and maritime readiness is not established. Naval capability rose 25%, matching nominal spending. The figure is useless because inflation cancels all growth. Question 9 Carrier A reroutes on Monday; B does not, but B sails Thursday. Does B refute a Monday security-pressure hypothesis? Yes; different carrier behavior disproves it. No; align exposure times before comparison. Yes; the second carrier is inherently more independent. Question 10 Three authorities announce an integrated corridor, but its shared road carries 15 shipments and the client needs 20. What does the statement alone change operationally? It immediately raises throughput to the ports' combined 30 slots. It does not lift the documented road limit; five need new permission or another link. It removes any need to verify bookings because it is joint. Question 11 A plant uses 60 units daily, holds 900, and loses its main supplier. An alternative sends 30 daily after 10 days. Roughly when is stock exhausted? After 15 days because 900÷60=15, ignoring later inflow. After 20 days: 300 remain at day 10 and net draw is then 30 daily. Never, because any alternate supplier removes the deficit. Question 12 Port A has 9 delays in 90 shipments and B has 8 in 40. What initial comparison is sound? B is better because eight delays are fewer than nine. A is 10% and B 20%, subject to comparable cargo and period. The rates are equal because counts differ by only one. Question 13 A facility needs 80 water units daily, receives 60 and has 400 usable units stored. How long does the fixed deficit remain covered? Five days from dividing stock by total daily demand. Twenty days from 400 divided by the 20-unit daily gap. There is no gap because 60 of 80 is supplied. Question 14 Two warehouses in different buildings share one delivery-data provider. What is missed if they are treated as independent backups? Provider failure may stop order release at both sites. Different buildings make a data outage impossible. The stores must have identical capacity. Question 15 A quote for diverting ten shipments rises from 10 to 14 each; the client ceiling is 120 before other fees. What happened to the original plan? It remains within the ceiling because shipment count is unchanged. It now costs 140, twenty above the ceiling, requiring quantity or authority review. It now costs 112 because eight shipments are automatically enough. Question 16 A one-year price is fixed, while the permit is unissued and demand fluctuates. Which axes best serve a one-year decision scenario? Fixed price and road-logo color. Permit issuance and demand change after checking their relative independence. Logo color and demand because they are very different. Question 17 The corridor data platform works, but road capacity remains 15 against demand of 20. What can the platform do? Automatically raise physical capacity to twenty. Reveal the five-shipment backlog early and support another route without creating capacity. Prove that actual demand cannot exceed fifteen. Question 18 With weights 50% cost, 30% reliability and 20% flexibility, an option scores (4,3,4). What is its weighted total? 3.7 out of five after applying weights in order. 11 out of five from adding raw scores. 4.0 out of five because cost and flexibility match. Question 19 A trial costs 25 with later expansion for 90; a full contract now costs 100. Which cost statement is sound? The trial is always cheaper because it starts at twenty-five. Trial plus expansion is 115, fifteen above full; value depends on learning and avoided regret. The trial costs ninety because the first twenty-five is unrelated. Question 20 Option D loses (10,50) and E (30,30) in two cases. What is each option's maximum regret? D forty and E twenty after subtracting each option's own mean. Both twenty after subtracting the best loss within each case. D fifty and E thirty because regret equals worst loss. Question 21 A road carries 15 shipments against demand of 20, while a fixed warehouse offers 20 slots. Which executive statement is accurate? Pay for fixed storage because twenty slots mean twenty deliveries. Extra slots do not raise current road throughput; compare flexible fifteen with expansion and review conditions. Cancel all storage because the road is below demand. Question 22 Three road slots disappear for one day then return; expansion requires two consecutive days. What follows? Expand immediately so the warning is not missed. Log and verify the signal, but do not activate the two-day pivot yet. Erase the day because the alert did not persist. Question 23 Review finds two nominal suppliers depend on the same intermediate factory. What repairs the conclusion? Retain a diversification claim because supplier names differ. Expose the shared failure point and seek an independent processor or recovery-covering stock. Add a generic residual-risk phrase without changing advice. Question 24 The adviser recommends six shipments; the client authorizes only four. Which result record is sound? Rewrite the old recommendation as four to match execution. Keep the six-shipment advice and four-shipment authorization, then assess the four executed. Attribute the four-shipment result to six because the objective was shared. Question 25 A dated notice adds a document for one cargo class; an anonymous story alleges a ban on an entire region. What message is accurate? The port is closed to the region's residents. The added condition concerns the named class; a general ban is unverified and needs issuer clarification. There is no risk because the notice does not say ban. Create a free account to mark your answers and save your progress.