Diagnosis and decision boundaries Review questions Diagnosis and decision boundaries This module turns a broad wish to improve attainment into a bounded problem with a group, period, denominator, and source. Learners separate a signal from possible explanations and check whether criteria or participants changed before comparing results. They build competing hypotheses and a low-cost test that can distinguish them instead of blaming a teacher or pupil from one number. They then compare importance, readiness, equity, and authority to prepare a conditional priority memo. Outputs include a problem card, evidence matrix, hypothesis log, and inspectable learning aim. Worked cases show how changing denominators or absent pupils alter an inference and why resource decisions remain with the authorized owner rather than the analyst.
Review questions Test your understanding with these questions. Marking and saved results are available with a free account.
Question 1 In classes A and B, 18/30 and 9/29 failed to explain the denominator on comparable checks. Which statement belongs on the problem card now? There is a difference that calls for reviewing work samples and attendance before explaining its cause. Class A's teacher caused the gap, so begin formal appraisal. Class B met the improvement target because its failure proportion is lower. The denominators are close, so 18−9 estimates the teaching effect. Question 2 Referrals went from 14 of 80 to 19 of 120, while the referral criterion changed. What is the first defensible reading? The problem increased because 19 exceeds 14. The count rose, but the rate fell from 17.5% to about 15.8%; a causal comparison must wait. The problem definitely improved because the rate fell. No rate can be calculated because the criterion changed. Question 3 A dashboard says proficiency rose from 62% to 68%, but the threshold fell from 70 to 65 points and assessed pupils fell from 100 to 75. What comes first? Recompare on a common criterion and comparable group, or start a new baseline Scale the successful intervention immediately because the rise is six points Average 62 and 68 to remove criterion drift Ignore missing pupils and use 75 because it is newest Question 4 Thirty-six of 40 full attenders passed, versus 24 of 40 nonattenders. Which conclusion do these data alone permit? The program caused a 30-percentage-point gain There is a descriptive 90% versus 60% gap; baseline and selection need checking before attribution No nonattender passed because they lacked support Drop nonattenders from the report to make the effect estimate more precise Question 5 Pupils struggle with a word problem. Directions may be unclear or the concept may be unknown. Which check best separates the hypotheses? Ask the teacher which cause seems likelier and adopt it Repeat the same test and treat any gain as proof of clear directions Have a sample explain the task, then solve it with clearer directions and check whether conceptual errors persist Move directly to formal teacher appraisal Question 6 A school delivered only two of ten planned reading sessions, and the final check did not improve. What is the soundest initial interpretation? Guided reading has been shown ineffective The result cannot establish the method's effectiveness before investigating underdelivery Increase text difficulty because scores did not rise Remove delivery data from the report to avoid affecting interpretation Question 7 A large reading gap appears in two noncomparable measures, while a common marking rubric can be trialed this week. What is the practical first priority? Set a binding school target using the average of the two measures Buy a schoolwide program because the gap matters Test a common rubric to repair measurement, then reassess the scale of need Abandon reading because current data are weak Question 8 There is no dependable baseline for identifying a main idea. Which aim is defensible now? Establish a common-rubric baseline in week one, then have the decision owner approve a target and test explanations on a new passage Guarantee 95% in a month because an aim must be numeric Assess only the rehearsed passage to demonstrate effectiveness Exclude the weakest pupils from the denominator so their need does not hide gains Create a free account to mark your answers and save your progress.