Requisition and job analysis · Lesson 1

From vacancy to hiring decision

6 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Document a workload gap, alternatives, and authority in a reviewable requisition.
Reading tools

A talent acquisition specialist receives a request: “We need another service analyst immediately.” The request may be justified, but it does not yet describe the work that cannot be completed, the cause of the gap, or the decision already authorized. A vacancy is an unoccupied position. A hiring need is a conclusion drawn from expected work, available capacity, and feasible alternatives. One does not automatically prove the other. Start with a focused conversation with the work manager and produce a reviewable requisition card: the task, evidence of need, timing, proposed engagement, who approves its cost, and the next authorized decision. Writing the card does not give the specialist authority to create a position or promise its terms to a candidate.

Ask first what changed. Someone may have left; demand may have grown; a new skill may be required; or work may have accumulated because a process is blocked. These causes call for different responses. Adding a person will not necessarily fix a delay caused by an approval queue. Conversely, permanent work that still requires an entry-level capability in six months may justify a role more than repeated overtime. Treat the manager's explanation as a hypothesis until you inspect suitable evidence: incoming volume, time required by case type, unfinished work, ordinary capacity, and error patterns. Exclude work the team should no longer perform before using volume to justify a post. Counting obsolete tasks can make a requisition look more compelling than it is.

Distinguish flow from stock. “120 new cases per week” is a flow; “18 cases open from previous weeks” is a stock. If the team closes 108 cases while 120 arrive, the stock grows by roughly 12 in a week, provided that the definition and time window are consistent and the mix of cases is similar. The ratio 108/120, or 90%, describes closures relative to arrivals in this example. It does not prove any individual's productivity. Some incoming cases may be harder, and some closed cases may be reopened. Ask how the numbers were counted before presenting them in a budget request. Do not add the 18-case backlog to 120 arrivals and call 138 the weekly demand: one figure is an existing balance and the other a week's movement.

Once you describe the gap, compare four kinds of response: reprioritize work, improve a process, move capacity internally or temporarily, and recruit externally. The specialist tests the feasibility of each option so the authorized owner can choose, rather than taking ownership of the budget decision. Automating a small checking step might be faster than hiring if that step causes the delay. Temporary support may fit a short seasonal peak. A stable workload requiring a particular capability on entry may justify a continuing role. Every alternative has a constraint: training and coverage for redeployment, quality control for process changes, contract duration for temporary help, and search plus onboarding time for recruitment. “One more person” is not an adequate specification without stating what the person will do and when that capacity can be used.

Use short but meaningful fields in the requisition. The reason field cites an observation and its date, rather than saying “very busy.” The output field describes observable work, such as triaging service requests and identifying items needing escalation within an agreed window. Capacity separates what is available now from what will soon be lost. Alternatives record what has been tried and its result, and what has not been tried and why. Authority names who has approved the post and budget, who agrees the selection criteria, and who may issue an offer. These fields are not paperwork for its own sake. They stop an untested assumption from becoming an advertisement for a poorly specified job.

The crucial decision point is what must be true before the vacancy is advertised. A manager might approve replacing a departing analyst without knowing whether the same job will resolve the service gap. If arrivals already exceeded capacity before departure, a like-for-like replacement restores the previous shortfall. The specialist neither rejects the request unilaterally nor promises two hires. Present two clear paths to the decision owner: replacement restores earlier capacity while leaving a measured gap, or a broader plan combines a defined role with process repair or further support. State what still needs measurement, such as handling time by case type, because a count of cases is not the same as hours of work.

When a path is approved, mark the boundary of the next task. Job analysis and entry criteria precede the advertisement and screening. Separate a capability needed to perform the work on entry from one that can be learned during onboarding and from a preference unrelated to the task. “Find someone like the previous employee” must not become a hidden selection criterion. Date the requisition card. If volume or budget changes, reconfirm the decision before continuing the search. Check that the manager and people team mean the same thing by each figure and that the authorized owner approved only the recorded next step. The card is useful because its evidence and decision are consistent, not because it has many fields.

Lesson summary

Distinguish a vacancy from a measured need, then link tasks to entry competencies. An old description or employer label cannot replace job analysis.