Services and the Three Lines Model
4 min read
Lesson objectives
- Explain Services and the Three Lines Model in a defined audit engagement.
- Resolve a case about Services and the Three Lines Model with evidence limits.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
The list of possible audit engagements can look broad: contract compliance, system security, management-report accuracy, or the culture of reporting errors. Classify each by the **question the work answers**, rather than the department visited. A compliance engagement compares conduct with specified requirements. An operational engagement examines process performance and its controls. A technology engagement addresses system and data risks. A reporting engagement examines how decision information is produced. Training managers to assess risks is advisory work if internal audit neither concludes on an existing condition nor takes over management's decision.
The IIA's Three Lines Model helps assign roles. The **governing body** oversees the organization and holds management accountable. **First-line roles** manage delivery of products and services and their associated risks, including frontline and back-office activities. **Second-line roles** support management with risk-related expertise, monitoring, and challenge. **The third line**, internal audit, provides independent, objective assurance and advice to the governing body and management. The model does not transfer ownership of risk to a second-line team, nor does finding a weak control make the auditor its operator. Management, through its roles, remains responsible for managing risk and operating controls; internal audit evaluates, reports, and advises without taking that responsibility.
Select a service in four steps. Identify the decision-maker and the real question: effectiveness of an existing control, or help choosing a future design? If assurance is sought, choose a relevant evaluation criterion such as a policy, performance objective, contract term, or applicable requirement. Identify obtainable evidence and access limits. Finally, examine independence and objectivity: did the team previously own the control or decide the design it proposes to test? This sequence keeps a busy list of activities from being mistaken for a useful conclusion. “Comprehensive audit” is not a substitute for a defined scope and an evidence-supported conclusion.
Assurance can address risk and control assessments, third-party contracts, IT security and privacy, performance and quality, operational and financial processes, regulatory compliance, organizational culture, and management reporting. Advice can include risk-and-control training, process mapping, benchmarking, due diligence, and early input on a system, control, or privacy-policy design. The activity label alone does not decide the service: mapping to help management redesign a process is advisory, while using a map to test an existing control can be part of assurance. Management still owns the design and implementation decision.
Lesson summary
Assurance can address risk and control assessments, third-party contracts, IT security and privacy, performance and quality, operational and financial processes, regulatory compliance, organizational culture, and management reporting. Advice can include risk-and-control training, process mapping, benchmarking, due diligence, and early input on a system, control, or privacy-policy design. The activity label alone does not decide the service: mapping to help management redesign a process is advisory, while using a map to test an existing control can be part of assurance. Management still owns the design and implementation decision.