Audit standards, ethics and independence
4 min read
Lesson objectives
- Distinguish engagement standards from professional conduct, identify a self-review threat, and choose a safeguard for an objective conclusion
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
An information systems audit should not begin with “Which control shall I test?” before its audience, scope, and decision authority are clear. An assurance engagement gathers evidence, compares it with stated criteria, and gives a conclusion limited to the work performed. Three layers matter. Professional standards govern how the engagement is planned, performed, documented, and reported. A code of ethics governs the auditor's conduct, interests, and handling of confidential information. The organization's procedure defines a control expected in that environment. Breaching a local procedure may become an audit finding without automatically being a breach of a professional standard. Equally, a technically sound control test does not resolve an auditor's conflict of interest.
ISACA describes the fifth edition of its IT Audit Framework, ITAF, as covering auditor roles and responsibilities and guidance for planning, performing, and reporting IT audit engagements. That describes the framework’s scope; it does not make every procedure within an organization a verbatim ITAF requirement. At the start of an engagement ask whether the team can obtain evidence, has the skill to understand the system, and can report an unwelcome result without pressure from the audited function. State each test criterion so that evidence can confirm or refute it. For example, “Every production change requires separate approval before implementation” is a valid case criterion if the organization’s approved policy says so. Without that policy, do not attribute the exact requirement to ISACA by assumption; inspect the engagement terms and applicable organizational requirements.
Objectivity means following the facts even when the conclusion disappoints management. A self-review threat arises when an auditor assesses a design or decision in which that auditor participated. Saying “I will be impartial” does not remove the effect on readers' confidence. Before accepting the assignment, the auditor discloses the earlier role to the engagement lead or authorized body and records it. Where feasible, another auditor assesses that control. If reassignment is impossible, the responsible authority evaluates the limitation and necessary disclosure; the auditor does not bury it in working papers. Confidentiality also affects evidence: a log containing personal data should not be circulated simply because it is useful. Define the audit need, access rights, and a less revealing retained copy.
Check your reasoning with two separate questions: Was I the right person to conduct the test, and was the subsequent evidence sufficient for the conclusion? A date comparison can be arithmetically correct while the professional threat remains. An independent reviewer may also discover that timestamps are unreliable and withhold an unsupported conclusion. ISACA's ethics code calls for objectivity, care, competence, confidentiality, and disclosure of significant facts. Here those duties become reviewable assignment, documentation, and reporting decisions rather than a personal declaration of honesty.
Lesson summary
Check your reasoning with two separate questions: Was I the right person to conduct the test, and was the subsequent evidence sufficient for the conclusion? A date comparison can be arithmetically correct while the professional threat remains. An independent reviewer may also discover that timestamp