Audit and Control Foundations and Responsibilities · Lesson 1
Who owns a control, and who reviews it?
8 min read
Lesson objectives
Separate management ownership of controls from internal audit's independent assessment by mapping an invoice process and its evidence.
Reading tools
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
Draw the transaction before assigning people to it:
a numbered request and requester
approval by someone with the required spending authority
a purchase order recording quantity and price
receipt evidence independent of the payment request
a supplier invoice with its identifier and date
and payment authorization and posting
At each step, identify the decision, decision maker, and durable record. A signature on an invoice alone does not prove receipt. It might demonstrate financial approval, but it must be linked to a receipt record and the order to support the full claim. If the match is automated, inspect the matching rules, user permissions, and exception log. An automated label says nothing by itself about whether the rule was configured correctly or whether someone handled the rejected transactions.
Management owns the process, its risks, and its controls. Purchasing requests within its authority, a manager approves within a stated limit, the storekeeper confirms quantity and condition, and finance reconciles the records and pays. Roles may be combined in a small organization, but management's responsibility does not transfer to the auditor. A risk or compliance function may help management set a policy and monitor it without becoming the owner of each transaction. Internal audit independently assesses whether controls are suitably designed and actually work, then reports evidence-backed conclusions and recommendations. The boundary protects objectivity. A person who configured vendor approval, authorized every change, and then audited those same choices would be reviewing their own work.
For an initial review, obtain the process narrative, authority matrix, duplicate-detection setting, exception log, and selected requests, orders, receipts, invoices, and payment records. Tie records together by transaction identifiers; inconsistent IDs can conceal a gap despite a large pile of files. Trace one paid item through the expected route and one exception through its approval path. This educational walkthrough does not support an overall effectiveness opinion. Two transactions cannot demonstrate an entire month's operation, and a verbal assurance cannot replace missing records. If the log is inaccessible, state the evidence limitation and design another procedure instead of guessing that the control passed or failed.
Keep three columns separate in a workpaper: what management says the control does, what a particular transaction shows, and what you can infer. A policy may say a different approver reviews a request. One item may show that person's signature. This supports a review for that item, not an assertion that every request was reviewed. If the creator and approver fields carry the same user, check the account identity, permission and event time before attributing misconduct to a person. Such precision protects staff as well as the conclusion: audit tests a demonstrable decision path rather than treating a record discrepancy as an accusation. Phrase the test so another reviewer can repeat it: for each selected payment in the stated period, is there a linked approved order and receipt, plus an authorized exception when quantity differs?
What happens to a control when its usual approver is away? Imagine a legitimate request waiting at the service desk while the manager is on leave. A job title and authority for a particular decision are different things. A useful delegation names the alternate, transaction class, financial limit and effective dates. It also prevents the alternate from reviewing a request they created. The system retains the appointment and its applicable version so an earlier approval can be explained. When the alternate changes after the leave period, previous records remain linked to the person authorized at that time. Examine suitability as well as the appointment: the alternate may understand the work but also be able to create a supplier, change its account and release payment. Management then needs separation or a specified compensating review before money leaves.
Lesson summary
Management owns control decisions; audit independently tests design and operation without approving the transactions it will review.