The Archaeological Record and Research Questions · Lesson 1

What counts as archaeological evidence and context?

8 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Explain What counts as archaeological evidence and context? with the evidence limits stated.
  • Produce a reviewable decision from fictional inputs.
Reading tools

A pottery sherd near a wall does not by itself show that the wall builders used the vessel. The sherd may have arrived in fill dumped after the wall fell out of use. Begin by identifying the kind of evidence, then ask where it was recorded, what it touches or cuts, and how it could have reached that position. A portable human-made object, such as a pottery sherd, is an artifact. A wall foundation or hearth pit is a feature that is recorded in place. Unworked seeds and animal remains may be ecofacts when they inform a question about human activity and the associated deposit. A shaped bone tool, however, needs its human modification recorded and may be classified as an artifact for the analysis at hand. These working classes do not prove age, authenticity, or function. [NPS, What Is Archeological Context, 2023; NPS, Archeology glossary, checked 2026-10-23]

Context is more than a map point. It includes the stratigraphic unit containing a find, that unit's relationship to a wall or cut, and associations with other evidence. “Sherd from unit U12 above floor F3” permits a more constrained inference than “sherd near the wall.” Even objects in the same fill need not have been used at the same time: redeposited soil can mix earlier material. Ask whether a deposit remains where it first formed, was brought in from elsewhere, or was later disturbed by roots or a recent cut. A change in that formation account can change the inference before it changes the object label. Record the observation separately from the proposed explanation. [NPS, What Is Archeological Context, 2023; Historic England, Archaeological Recording Manual, 2018]

A useful preliminary register gives each entry a unique identifier, a description of what is visible without an assumed function, a provisional class, a recorded unit, relevant relationships, disturbance indicators, and a reasoned confidence note. “Kitchen” is an interpretation, not a visual description of pottery and bone. It requires comparison of their distribution, heat traces, stratigraphic association, and rival uses of the space. An unknown unit or missing image source should be marked unknown. In this course the records are hypothetical desk exercises. Work at a real site requires the competent authority's process and is outside the learner's authorization here.

When another team hands you a box, begin with a practical question: can you reconnect each object to the record of its discovery? A box label may survive while the labels on individual bags become detached. The label establishes the box's project origin but provides a weaker link for any single object. Compare the transfer list, bag counts, descriptions and earlier photographs before assigning detailed locations. A match in material and colour can help identify an object. Establishing its excavation unit requires a preserved link among photograph, label and field record. Separating these tasks prevents a familiar mistake: treating a known object's identity as certainty about its lost location. You can describe manufacture and condition accurately while recording the deposit as unknown. This retains useful information and states what kinds of inference remain defensible.

Lesson summary

A pottery sherd near a wall does not by itself show that the wall builders used the vessel.