Transparent prioritisation
4 min read
Lesson objectives
- Prioritise needs using severity, reach, feasibility and community preference without hiding tradeoffs; output a recorded decision.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
A diagnosis may uncover several real needs while resources cannot address all of them at once. Professional prioritisation should not let the loudest group win by default, nor pretend that a scorecard settles ethical value automatically. Published criteria allow people to see why one need was chosen now and what remains for review. Four useful criteria here are severity of harm without action, breadth of those affected, feasibility within the initiative's resources and authority, and the priority stated by affected people. A small group may require urgent action when harm is severe, so reach alone cannot decide. Feasibility must not become a concealed excuse to exclude people who are harder to reach.
Define each score before rating options. For example, a severity score of three can mean a clear risk of losing access to an essential service in the case, while one means a delay to a non-urgent benefit. This is a local teaching scale, not a universal standard. State weights and why they were chosen, then show each option's evidence and uncertainty. A weighted score is the sum of each criterion's score multiplied by its weight. Weights must total one, and criteria must use the same rating range. The calculation makes tradeoffs visible; it does not override a safety obligation or a missing voice. Treat the result as a recommendation open to challenge and revision, not as a final moral verdict.
Test sensitivity rather than stopping at a total. Suppose inspection finds that the entrance does not actually impede access. B's severity falls from three to one, bringing its score to 1.75; A at 2.35 leads if other scores stay fixed. A concrete changed fact alters the recommendation. If conversations with previously unheard people instead reveal that room hours are more harmful than assumed, revise A's severity with that evidence. Do not change weights after seeing the result simply to produce a favoured winner. Discuss any new weighting openly and preserve the previous decision record.
Lesson summary
Community context and needs diagnosis: Prioritise needs using severity, reach, feasibility and community preference without hiding tradeoffs; output a recorded decision.