Risk and prioritization · Lesson 2

Scenarios, likelihood and impact

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Compare plausible emergency scenarios without mistaking impact for probability and document uncertainty.
Reading tools

A scenario is a conditional account of what could happen if a sequence of events occurs; it is not a prediction that the sequence will happen. It helps teams test dependencies and decisions when frequency or severity data are sparse. Start with a specific hazard and a time and place boundary. Describe the initiating event, a service dependency that could fail, the effect on people and service, and the signal that would trigger a decision update. These links replace an unhelpful statement such as 'a disaster might happen.' The Sendai Framework's priority of understanding disaster risk supports this discipline, but the figures and thresholds in this lesson are teaching choices, not international standards.

A colored matrix does not manufacture a probability. If a team records 'high impact' and 'low confidence,' the first is a qualitative judgement about consequences in a scenario; the second is a judgement about information quality. Red is not a percentage chance. Adding an impact score of three to a probability score of two is unjustified unless the scales and the use of their sum have been defined and validated for this decision. Display the impact, the origin of each input, uncertainty and a feasible action side by side. Then test sensitivity: would the order of two actions change if one plausible input changed? If it would not, the immediate decision is relatively stable. If it would, checking that input should move forward in the work plan.

Worked solution: set a two-hour decision horizon from the hypothetical start. In scenario one, the lift operates, but the wet entrance may restrict access. Check the ground route and whether staff can guide visitors safely. In scenario two, the lift and lighting cease if the generator fails. Access for the eight people and safe exit for everyone are distinct questions requiring the responsible organization's decision. Put 60 in the present-occupancy column and eight as a subset requiring access support; do not add them into 68. The common preparatory action is to test the generator and the alternate route before relying on them, recording an owner, time and observed result. A test date alone cannot yield a probability of power loss, and a route drawn on a plan is not proof of usability.

Sensitivity analysis changes one fact at a time. If a documented field check finds that the ground entrance is closed when water accumulates, keeping the lift operational alone will not guarantee access. The urgent check shifts to a safe entry and exit route or a decision by the authorized body to suspend reception. If a generator test shows it starts and actually powers both lighting and lift, the second failure pathway becomes less immediate, but does not disappear. Fuel, run time and maintenance still matter. State the changed fact explicitly and leave the occupancy count unchanged in this comparison; otherwise readers cannot tell why the decision moved.

Lesson summary

Scenario decision matrix