Framing the futures question · Lesson 4

Decision criteria and reversibility

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Apply decision criteria and reversibility to a conditional choice and justify its limits and review signpost.
Reading tools

A foresight question can be well framed while the resulting choice remains confused because the team has not said what makes an option acceptable. “Choose the best solution” leaves open best for whom, over which horizon, and under what constraints. Begin with a criterion that can be observed or clearly described: access for people unable to use the digital channel, waiting time, first-year cost, or the ability to revise the choice after a new signal. Writing a criterion does not turn the team's preference into a fact about residents. Name the decision owner, whose experience should be heard, and when proposed weights will be reviewed.

Separate three kinds of conditions. An eligibility condition is a bound an option may not cross, such as an approved budget ceiling or stated waiting limit. A comparison criterion distinguishes eligible options, such as cost per completed request or coverage of distant neighborhoods. A switching condition says when to reconsider the choice, such as a sustained rise in demand from a particular group across comparable periods. Folding eligibility into a weighted point total is a mistake: a high total can conceal failure of a basic access requirement. If a proposed bound has not been approved, do not present it as an official rule.

Reversibility is a scale, not a yes-or-no label. Buying a building, leasing a room for a year, and running a four-week mobile trial differ in sunk commitments, cancellation time, and information gained before the next step. Put them on a commitment ladder: a low-cost observation, a bounded trial, conditional expansion, then a longer commitment. A trial is not automatically superior. Waiting may be harmful if current access is already below an acceptable limit. State both the cost of delay and the cost of locking in too early.

A six-part decision card names the decision due this quarter, the horizon of its effects, options actually available, eligibility bounds, comparison criteria and their measurements, and the condition for reopening the decision. When a coverage denominator is missing, record “unverified” rather than award zero or full points. Do not combine unlike measures into a single score before defining units, direction, and weights. A separate table may be more honest than a manufactured total.

Lesson summary

Separate eligibility from preference, then compare delay and lock-in costs before staging reviewable commitments.