Actors, concepts and analytical tools · Lesson 3

Levels of explanation and proximate causes

4 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Distinguish the elements of Levels of explanation and proximate causes in the case.
  • Produce a three-level causal grid with reasons and limits.
Reading tools

After a close encounter between vessels associated with two states, it is tempting to settle on one explanation: “the captain rushed” or “the states are rivals.” Either may matter, but a useful explanation first states what outcome it is trying to explain and what evidence would bear on it. To explain a sharp turn at 10:00, bridge communications and the captain's orders may matter. To explain why escalation was feared throughout a year, institutions and the two states' security relationship may matter more. A single event cannot automatically establish the character of an entire political relationship.

International relations offers the tool of levels of analysis. The individual level examines leaders' perceptions and choices. The state level examines institutions, procedures and domestic pressures. The international-system level examines the distribution of capabilities, patterns of interaction and expectations among states. Kenneth Waltz's Man, the State, and War offers three explanatory images close to this division. The levels are not a ranking from correct to incorrect. A structural condition does not erase the role of an individual's decision. Each level directs attention to different observations and different ways a claim might be disproved.

Separate a proximate cause from an enabling condition. A radio message that did not arrive may directly affect a vessel's course at a particular moment. A procedure with no clear reviewer of warnings might help explain recurring communication failures. An atmosphere of rivalry may make both sides interpret an incident more sharply, but does not by itself establish exactly how the vessel moved that minute. Draw a sequence: warning detected, bridge interpretation, maneuver, response from the other vessel, and political decision after the event. Every link requires evidence; assumptions about national intentions cannot fill a missing link.

The worked analysis makes a testable hypothesis at each level. Individual: perhaps the captain misunderstood a warning. Obtain the bridge recording and an account from the crew; evidence that the warning never arrived would undermine this version. State: perhaps the ministry's process escalated an unverified report. Inspect the review steps and their timestamps; an independent review before the public statement might undermine the claim. System: perhaps rivalry increased threat expectations. That would require repeated evidence of both sides' conduct, not this incident alone. The safe conclusion is that the timeline makes communication the first question to investigate, while the final cause of the maneuver remains unsettled. A hypothesis does not become established merely because it appears in a table.

Lesson summary

One defensible solution gives more weight to the state-level procedure because the required confirmation is absent, subject to checking that the log is complete. It does not assign an individual mistake without identifying who owned the step, and it does not infer that rivalry caused the minute-by-minute decision. Check that the response uses the supplied times accurately, does not equate message arrival with understanding, and names evidence that could disprove its provisional conclusion. This output can be evaluated; “many factors interacted” cannot.