Classifying a dispute and its limits
6 min read
Lesson objectives
- Classify a disagreement by its observable evidence, distinguish research coding from legal classification, and record what remains unknown.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
What is being classified, and for what purpose?
In everyday speech, conflict may mean disagreement over a decision, a strained relationship between groups, or organized armed fighting. A shared label does not transfer the rules of one category to another. Start with an observable account: who did what, when, who stated a claim, and which independent record supports it? Then name the purpose of classification. A local dialogue design needs information about parties, issues and safety. A research dataset requires its own definition and time unit. A legal assessment of armed conflict calls for different facts and legal criteria and should be undertaken by suitably qualified people. A casualty threshold borrowed from a research database cannot make that legal determination. This lesson teaches a bounded educational decision; it does not classify a real incident in law.
A disagreement is an observable difference over an issue or decision; correcting one factual mistake may resolve some disagreements. Conflict analysis becomes more demanding when interests or fears diverge, interactions repeat, and rules governing resources or influence shape relationships. Do not assume that all tension is violent, or that no violence means no grievance. Distinguish a stated position such as 'give us the evening slot' from a possible interest such as safe access for people who work during the day. A possible interest is a hypothesis until someone checks it. Note who is absent from a meeting: silence could reflect exclusion, fear or satisfaction, and an attendance sheet alone cannot distinguish these explanations.
For its state-based conflict data, UCDP defines armed conflict through an incompatibility about government or territory, the use of armed force between two parties of which at least one is a state government, and at least 25 battle-related deaths in a calendar year. All elements matter; the number alone does not define the case. The threshold is neither a universal boundary between social conflict and violence nor a legal threshold for international humanitarian law. The ICRC's 2024 account explains that legal classification of international and non-international armed conflict applies factual and legal criteria concerning the parties and hostilities. A case absent from UCDP's dataset cannot therefore be declared legally outside armed conflict on that ground alone. If the facts are insufficient, write 'undetermined on the available facts' instead of filling the gap with a reassuring assumption.
A five-line bounded classification memo
Write five lines:
- (1) observed event, time and source
- (2) parties and claims as stated, not imagined
- (3) the practical category needed for the present decision
- (4) any research or legal definition that is actually relevant and the missing evidence for its elements
- and (5) a safe, revisable next action
Keep 'we found no evidence' separate from 'we established this did not occur'. If one witness calls a crowd threatening but describes no act, keep that adjective in the account column rather than the facts column. If a document lists injuries, do not silently convert them into battle-related deaths. A practical response may be to collect accounts safely or change a meeting format while withholding any legal classification. This format lets another reviewer correct one evidentiary step without rewriting the whole story.
Lesson summary
In everyday speech, conflict may mean disagreement over a decision, a strained relationship between groups, or organized armed fighting. A shared label does not transfer the rules of one category to another. Start with an observable account: who did what, when, who stated a claim, and which independent record supports it? Then name the purpose of classification. A local dialogue design needs information about parties, issues and safety. A research dataset requires its own definition an