Peace, conflict and the limits of classification · Lesson 3

Actors, relationships and claims

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Construct a revisable actor-and-relationship map that separates expressed positions, possible interests, influence, representation and evidentiary confidence.
Reading tools

An actor map is more than a name list

An actor map helps explain who shapes an issue, who is affected and how actions connect them. It is not a diagram placing everybody at a meeting on one side and every absent person on another. Define the issue and boundary first: hall allocation for the coming month, not every relationship in a city. For each actor, record a role, stated position, possible interest, means of influence and evidence source. Separate the booking decision maker from a hall user and from someone affected by access who has no committee voice. One person may have several roles. Avoid treating 'youth', 'women' or 'management' as homogeneous blocs without evidence. The UN conflict analysis practice note calls for attention to stakeholders, drivers, dynamics and context, with the method tailored to the decision's purpose.

Connect two nodes only when you can describe the relation: a binding decision, exchange of a resource, reliance on information, a stated objection or documented cooperation. Sharing a room is not evidence of trust or hostility. Label the arrow's direction and meaning. An arrow from a booking committee to an association may mean 'assigns a slot'; an arrow back may mean 'submits a request or objection'. Neither proves that association members trust the committee. Add the evidence date and strength next to the link. The order of consultations may need changing if a lone spokesperson proves unable to convey the views of people he claims to represent.

A position is what a party asks for now; an interest is an account of what that choice would achieve; a need is a deeper condition that might be met through several options. 'Thursday belongs to us' is a position. Attendance after work might be an interest, but check it rather than infer it from an organizational label. Some members may need physical access or safe travel, which changes the range of viable options. Do not use a guessed interest to publicly correct or dismiss a party's own words. Ask who benefits from the existing rule and who bears its cost. UN Women's guidance on gender-responsive conflict analysis explains how power and representation can make an actor map incomplete when only visible voices are used. That is a method of inquiry, not proof of a particular pattern in fictional the city.

Lesson summary

An actor map helps explain who shapes an issue, who is affected and how actions connect them. It is not a diagram placing everybody at a meeting on one side and every absent person on another. Define the issue and boundary first: hall allocation for the coming month, not every relationship in a city. For each actor, record a role, stated position, possible interest, means of influence and evidence source. Separate the booking decision maker from a hall user and from someone affected by