Process safety scope and leadership · Lesson 2

Accountability and worker participation in hazard decisions

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Assign hazard-decision ownership, performance, consultation and notification while preserving dissent.
Reading tools

In process safety, saying ‘everyone owns safety’ does not assign a decision. For a decision affecting a critical barrier, an operator may know what actually happens on shift, an instrument technician may know the test result, a process engineer may understand design limits, and an operations manager may hold the authority to permit or restrict operation under site rules. If these roles blur, each person may assume somebody else approved the risk. A decision record should distinguish four actions: who is accountable for the final choice, who performs the work, whose direct knowledge must be consulted, and who must be informed before operation. Consultation does not transfer accountability to a worker; managerial authority does not erase a technician's adverse evidence. The US OSHA standard requires employee participation for processes within its US scope. IChemE's leadership framework describes expectations and everyday actions that support technical systems. We use these bounded ideas to teach a management method rather than a universal legal rule.

A RACI map is an aid, not a vote on the hazard: Responsible performs a task, Accountable owns one clear decision, Consulted supplies knowledge before the decision, and Informed needs the outcome. Start with the precise question, not the name of a committee. ‘May the pump continue with its vibration alarm disabled until tomorrow's test?’ differs from ‘Who repairs the alarm?’ The first may require input from operations, maintenance, engineering and process safety, while a qualified instrument specialist performs the repair. If consultation reveals an unknown technical limit or an outdated procedure, do not fill the approval box by assumption. Record the gap, its owner, the answer date and any interim control that site rules actually permit. Escalate when the gap exceeds the decision owner's authority or a production target conflicts with an operating limit. Keep the substance of a dissenting view and the reason it was accepted or rejected; an attendance sheet alone cannot explain the decision later.

Lesson summary

Assign hazard-decision ownership, performance, consultation and notification while preserving dissent.