Fleet records and operating demand · Lesson 3

Measure vehicle utilization with the right denominator

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Calculate use while separating fleet days, available days, assigned days and record coverage
Reading tools

The claim 'the fleet is 70% utilized' is incomplete until the unit and denominator are defined. Assigned days divided by all fleet days indicates how much owned capacity produced work; assigned days divided by available service days indicates how effectively dispatch used capacity that was ready. These answer different questions. Define one vehicle-day as one vehicle over a specified operating day, then choose the calendar: scheduled service days or every calendar day. Excluding weekends from demand while leaving them in the denominator lowers the rate by design rather than by dispatch performance. If workshop days are removed from the operational denominator, keep them visible in a separate availability measure; dispatch utilization can improve while overall readiness deteriorates. Utilization alone does not determine the right fleet size, because peak demand, payload class and vehicle location may make a rarely used standby unit necessary.

Build a daily status table before dividing. For this measure, statuses are mutually exclusive: assigned to a job, available but unassigned, out of service, or unverified. A vehicle completing two trips in one day still contributes one assigned vehicle-day; trips per day is a different indicator. Never turn a missing status into 'available' or 'unused', because that silently changes both denominator and conclusion. Define data coverage as verified-status days divided by expected days, and report it beside the rate. If some assets run partial shifts, document a switch to vehicle-hours; do not mix a vehicle-hour with a vehicle-day. Keep vehicle classes, calendars and availability definitions consistent across branches or months. If they differ, state that a performance comparison is not valid until the figures are recalculated to a common definition.

First reconcile the status total: 6+9+25=40, matching the 40 vehicle-days. Available days are 40−6=34, also 9+25. Dispatch use of available capacity is 25÷34=73.53%; assigned days as a share of all fleet days are 25÷40=62.5%; and availability is 34÷40=85%. These figures are compatible because the first has denominator 34 and the second 40. Their difference exposes the effect of workshop downtime on total capacity. None proves that a van should be sold. Examine daily demand, duty class, breakdown cover and peak periods. If the nine idle days are scattered across different vehicles, there may be no whole redundant vehicle at a peak. Present all three rates with definitions and a daily matrix, then recommend a peak review before a sizing decision. If four unverified days later appear in the report source, do not relabel them as available; correct the sample and coverage and seek source evidence before recalculating.

After the aggregate rate, split the daily matrix by vehicle class rather than ranking assets by low use and proposing to sell the lowest. A refrigerated van idle for five days cannot automatically be replaced by a busy standard van; test the cooling duty, its timing and vehicle location before reassignment or disposal. Examine the pattern of the nine idle days. Concentration at weekends may point to a service-design question, while coincidence with other vehicles' peak loads may mean needed standby cover. Also separate 'assigned' from productive work: a trip cancelled after dispatch needs a cancellation code and actual distance so the indicator does not rise without delivered value. Link any action to a testable hypothesis: trial a vehicle reassignment for two weeks, then compare unserved requests, waiting time and breakdown days. Stop or revise the change if service deteriorates even when average utilization rises.

Lesson summary

Calculate use while separating fleet days, available days, assigned days and record coverage