Learner, context, and constraint analysis
6 min read
Lesson objectives
- Build an audience and constraint card from partial device and interview evidence, marking unknowns for validation.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
After identifying a learnable performance component, ask who needs to practice it and under what conditions they will use it. “New employees” is not a sufficient audience description. Some may be experienced in customer service but unfamiliar with this system's categories; some may know the categories but use a small phone during work; others may work in a second language. Learner analysis is not a way to attach fixed labels to people. It reveals conditions that affect examples, media, and support. Collect only information needed for design, and distinguish verified facts, hypotheses to check, and preferences for which an option could be provided.
Start from a concrete decision. To classify requests, a worker needs to understand the two category definitions, see the request text, consult the decision rule, and route a case in the work setting. Ask what language real requests use, whether the rule is current and documented, whether shifts allow a live session, whether headphones or reliable access are available, and how much time staff can devote before returning to the queue. These answers turn “make a polished video” into a specification: searchable text, short examples, resumable practice, and the decision rule at the point of use.
Separate learner characteristics from environmental conditions. Prior knowledge is checked with an initial question or task, not inferred from age or job title. Access involves an interface operable by keyboard, an alternative for meaningful visual information, and text for audio when needed; it does not require a diagnosis from a learner. Language analysis concerns actual workplace terms and the meaning of response options. The environment includes device, connection, time, permissions, and available support. Learners may benefit from different ways to reach a concept or show understanding. CAST's UDL Guidelines offer a framework for considering barriers and options; they do not automatically certify a product as suitable for everyone.
Use an audience card with columns for design decision, evidence, confidence, and next check. Leave out attributes that change no decision. For example, if system logs show connection interruptions at field sites, provide a lightweight text alternative and resumable activity, then test on a comparable phone and connection. If three interviewees find the term “reschedule” ambiguous, inspect a sample of requests and the organization's wording before adding a definition and example. Their comments do not establish that all employees share the problem.
Make the preproduction check small and specific. Where feasible, show a prototype to a worker from each shift, including someone using a phone and keyboard. Ask them to find the “temporary postponement” rule and classify a novel message. Record where they struggle, time to reach the rule, and whether the problem is wording, navigation, or access. Three people are not statistically representative, but their attempts can expose early defects. If subject experts disagree on the category boundary, pause authoring that case until the rule owner resolves it. An ambiguous answer key does not become acceptable merely because it has been entered into a quiz.
The audience card has limits. Do not sort people into fixed “learning styles” without evidence, and do not treat visual or audio options as substitutes for actual accessibility checks. If the organization has a formal access requirement, obtain its version and scope from its owner. A specialist can say which options were chosen to reduce identified barriers and which conditions were tested. A claim that an experience is “fully accessible” needs more evidence than a couple of interviews.
Lesson summary
After identifying a learnable performance component, ask who needs to practice it and under what conditions they will use it.