Questions and research design · Lesson 2

Matching the inquiry approach to the question

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Distinguish a meaning question from rate or effect estimation.
  • Justify qualitative, quantitative or mixed design against the decision need.
  • State the inference boundary of each design.
Reading tools

A method follows the question and intended inference; it is not a declaration of the researcher’s preferred tool. If a library team asks ‘How do users understand an error message?’, it needs an account of meaning, sequence and differences in experience. A semi-structured interview lets a participant interpret the wording and the interviewer ask a neutral follow-up. ‘What proportion of booking attempts stopped at the payment step?’ instead requires defined attempts, a defined stopping event, a denominator and a record covering the relevant period. Neither question replaces the other. A rich account does not produce a rate, and a counter does not necessarily explain why a person stopped. One project may need both questions when the decision depends on extent and explanation. A mixed methods design then specifies in advance where the results will be integrated.

The assumptions about knowledge differ as well. A researcher developing an interpretation from participants’ accounts asks how a category emerged and how the researcher’s own position affected collection and interpretation. A researcher estimating a proportion needs defined variables, a sampling frame and an account of error or bias suited to the design. This does not make qualitative work uncontrolled or quantitative work automatically neutral; each has distinct quality decisions. In a mixed study, state what each strand contributes and why they are brought together. Do interviews explain an unexpected numeric pattern, help construct survey items, or run alongside a measure for comparison? A small poll added after interviews without a connecting question does not by itself constitute meaningful mixed methods integration.

Lesson summary

The question determines evidence: interviews illuminate experience, defined records estimate rates, and mixed design links a pattern with an account when both are needed. Integration is planned explicitly; temporal association is not causal proof.