Questions and research design · Lesson 3

Choosing a qualitative approach and bounding the case

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Distinguish case, lived experience, culture and emerging process by question and unit of analysis.
  • Justify an approach with consistent sampling and data.
Reading tools

Approach names are methodological commitments, not decoration. A case study examines a bounded system, such as one programme’s move to online booking during a particular term, using accounts, records and observations to understand how its parts worked in context. If the question concerns the meaning of waiting as lived by people who experienced it, a lived-experience approach may fit; the focus is their experience rather than the performance of one organisation. To describe a group’s practices and shared meanings in its setting, a passing interview is not enough to label the work ethnography. Appropriate presence and observation are needed. To develop an explanation of a changing social process, such as how learners move from hesitation to help seeking, a grounded theory approach may fit if comparison and ongoing analysis guide recruitment of later cases. The differences concern purpose, unit of analysis and construction of evidence. A name alone cannot supply depth.

Begin by naming the object: a particular service case, shared experience across people, a group practice, or a process whose stages need explanation. Test fit with two questions: which absent data would defeat the approach’s claim, and what are the boundaries of time, place and people? In a case study, only interviewing the manager may miss the pathway’s complexity; seek distinct sources about the same case. For lived experience, do not average away meaningful differences among participants. Do not call two brief observations extended ethnographic engagement. Do not announce a theory from three selected quotations without systematic comparison and development of categories. A straightforward qualitative descriptive study can be more truthful than borrowing the name of a tradition that the available work cannot enact.

Lesson summary

Choose an approach by question, unit of analysis and feasible evidence. A case examines a bounded system; lived experience examines meaning; ethnography studies group practice; grounded theory develops process through iterative comparison. An honest descriptive study is better than an unsupported label.