Claim framing and verification plan · Lesson 1

Decompose a claim into testable units

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Produce a claim card that distinguishes events from people, names the time window and place, and states what the evidence cannot establish.
Reading tools

Verification begins by identifying the proposition to be judged, before choosing a search tool. One sentence can contain four assertions: an event occurred, at a named place, in a specified period, with a stated magnitude. Separate them before searching. 'Complaints increased this week at the centre' is not a single operational question. What counts as a complaint? Which centre? When does the week start and end? Is the increase an absolute count or a share of all transactions? If a field is missing, record it as unspecified and identify the original record that might resolve it. Do not silently supply an answer.

A working claim card retains the quoted wording, the account or channel on which it appeared without treating that account as the original creator, a link and capture time, and a decomposition into subject, predicate, quantity, denominator, place and period. Add evidence that could support each unit, evidence that could contradict it, and the person allowed to decide. These fields prevent a narrow observation from becoming a broad conclusion. Suppose a queue log lists 11 late requests among 38 requests on a specified day. The ratio is 11÷38≈28.9% of requests, not 28.9% of customers: a customer could submit several requests. Nor may we divide 11 by 42 because 42 comes from a separate count of people. A claim about people requires a lawful, appropriately minimized way to count affected unique people and all relevant people over the same period. A matching percentage is meaningless when numerator and denominator count different things.

Separate observation from interpretation. A screenshot of dated requests may show that entries appeared in an interface at capture time; alone it does not establish that the requests were real, that an entire organization was delayed, or that a system fault caused the delay. Make a three-column table: wording, classification as observation, inference or causal claim, and the evidence needed. For 'the image proves a crowded station in the hypothetical city on Tuesday morning', the crowd observation needs a defined visible area. the named city needs independent geographic features. Tuesday needs independent temporal evidence or converging clues. A caption containing the word the named city is a lead, not a location proof.

Watch for 'all', 'first', 'now', and 'official'. 'First image' makes a claim about the whole publication history, whereas the oldest version located by an investigator is bounded by indexed platforms and accessible archives. 'Now' shifts with reading time and may describe reposting rather than the event. 'Official' may describe a logo or account and does not alone show that the authorized body issued the statement. Rephrase an underspecified assertion as a testable question without silently changing its meaning: did the organization's authenticated channel publish this statement on a particular date, and did it concern this precise place and event? Keep the original wording beside the operational formulation so a reviewer can inspect the difference.

Choose decision states in advance: supported sufficiently within a narrow scope, contradicted, mixed, or unresolved. 'I found no evidence' is not equivalent to 'it never happened'; an inadequate query or unindexed record can explain absence. Equally, unresolved does not permit repeating the assertion as fact. Record why the process stopped, which units were resolved, and which need an original file, register or human review. Where people could be harmed, minimize personal data and assess escalation before sharing an image. This lesson develops a disciplined question, not a sweeping verdict from one observation.

Lesson summary

Define the counting unit, denominator, place and period before searching. State only the finding supported by that evidence.