A reproducible open research plan
5 min read
Lesson objectives
- Design a search log that distinguishes an original source from an indexed result and records each query's coverage limits.
Please sign in to use all the tools
Once you sign in, the reading tools are yours: larger or smaller text, typeface, line spacing, focus mode, highlighting and bold, and notes saved to your account and gathered in My study.
Once the assertion has been decomposed, build a source plan rather than a list of links. For each unit ask what record would have been created if the event occurred, who holds it, what public version can lawfully be consulted, and when it should have appeared. For a claim about a school notice, the likely primary source is the school or education authority, not a page repeating the text. For a request count, a reposted image can be a search lead but does not explain the original register's definition of a request or counting interval. Write at least two hypotheses: what you would expect if the claim is accurate, and what you would expect if it belongs to an older event or another place. Search then becomes a test instead of collecting matches for the first idea.
Use a log with columns for claim unit, search time and time zone, query language, literal query string, service used, its scope, results seen, URL opened, reading result, and next step. Preserve an unsuccessful query. An empty result does not mean the page does not exist: it might not be indexed, might be excluded from a crawler, or might use another spelling. Try an official name, abbreviation, locally used wording, and translation when justified; record why you changed wording. Do not rewrite the query history after learning the answer to make the investigation look shorter or more certain than it was.
Search operators narrow a search; they do not establish completeness. Quotation marks seek an exact phrase, and site: limits results to a domain or URL prefix in the search service, but it is not an inventory of every page on that site. If a notice is absent from a site: result, do not deny its existence before visiting the site's own news index, looking for alternate wording, or contacting the authority through a published channel. Ranking and visibility may differ by language, place and time. Log the query, time and final opened URL, not just the displayed result count. When comparing an original page with a cropped image, inspect the page title, date, publisher and body. A search snippet can place distant words together or reflect an older copy.
Plan two distinct paths where the question permits. One tracks the claim's provenance: an original account, statement or document. The other tests the asserted event with a record from another organization or an independently checkable clue. Two sites copying one notice are not two independent confirmations of the event. Draw a citation arrow from each repost to its parent. If the original notice cannot be reached, describe the limitation precisely: 'Two pages reproduced text attributed to the authority; the original was not found.' Do not say 'two authorities confirmed it'. Also distinguish public visibility from professional need. Personal information visible in a search result is not automatically necessary to collect or republish. Take the minimum information required and redact the working copy, while restricting any original that must lawfully be preserved.
After several search cycles with materially different hypotheses, inspect the value of continuing. Did an original source appear? Is there a plausible spelling or date that remains untested? Does the question require a non-public register or subject specialist? Record the stopping reason. Do not impose the same numeric threshold on every case: potential harm may require further review or an early hold. A good output is not twenty links but a small map of what was searched, what remained outside view, and how another reviewer can rerun the most important queries while understanding why results might vary.
Lesson summary
A useful search plan records queries, times and limits, separating originals from reposts and missing results from denial.