Claim framing and verification plan · Lesson 3

Source independence and citation chains

5 min read

Lesson objectives

  • Map a claim's citation chain and determine which observations are genuinely independent before weighing them.
Reading tools

Repetition of a story is not repetition of a witness. When four pages publish the same sentence, ask where it began. Did each page observe the event or consult a separate record, or did it copy an earlier page? Draw arrows from each republisher to the source it relied on, preserving the citation or textual match that supports the arrow. Four URLs may be one chain beginning with an unknown post. Counting URLs does not turn a chain into four confirmations. Name an evidence unit for each original observation: a video captured by someone, a published register, a documented interview, or an independent measurement. Record its maker, time, purpose, direct observation, and material relayed from others.

Independence belongs to the relationship between evidence items for a specific assertion, not to an institution as a whole. A reporter quoting an agency notice is not independent for the notice's number; the reporter might be independent for an interview they conducted. Build a claim-by-source matrix rather than assigning one credibility score to each URL. If two sources repeat a date that conflicts with an older register, do not vote among three links. Inspect the origin of the date, the time zone, and whether a page was revised. Preserve the version and correction time if the first source corrects itself. Different accounts may reflect memory error or a changed definition; disagreement alone is not proof that a person lied.

Weigh an item by its relevance to the question, proximity to the event, and testability, not popularity alone. An original register may establish a count but not a decision's cause. A spokesperson may explain the reason but not cover every site. A short video may establish a scene while leaving its duration and off-frame events unknown. Write both what each item supports and what it cannot support. Test alternatives: is the image old, is an account reposting a notice, or did 'closure' change meaning between a full shutdown and shorter hours? Seek the clue expected under each interpretation, such as a dated opening schedule or archived page.

Use a conflict table with columns for claim unit, item A, item B, relation, agreement or conflict, and proposed check. In the relation column write 'quotes A', 'independent for this observation', or 'unknown', not a bare 'independent'. If an eyewitness account carries a sensitive identity or location, do not disclose those details simply to demonstrate independence. An authorized reviewer may inspect them under restricted access. Protecting a person can reduce what is public, but it does not justify telling the public that everybody verified restricted material. Describe access limits honestly.

End with a decision on each proposition, not an overall grade for each source. Two independent records might agree that a closure occurred on a date while leaving its stated cause disputed. Say 'closure established for this location and period; water contamination remains unproved' if that is what the records support. If the case rests on one witness, say so. Revisit the chain when a new link appears: it may be a genuinely separate original or another copy of the same chain. Shares and comments alone never increase the number of original observations.

For a numeric independence test, suppose page A lists 24 cancelled appointments and B and C both repeat that number. Do not write '72 cancellations' or 'three sources confirmed 24': there is still one originating register if A's source is verified. If a separate attendance table says 19 appointments were not completed, neither add 24 and 19 nor vote between them. First compare whether cancellation and non-completion use the same definition, period and branch. Both figures could be correct for different populations. The immediate output is a unit-alignment table, not a favoured headline.

Lesson summary

Map each account's origin before weighing it. Reposts form one chain, and a source can be independent for one assertion but dependent for another.